This week, we’re focusing solely on the universally agreed upon encounter with the Mothman. On November 15, 1966, quite possibly one of the most important encounters with anomalous phenomena took place when two young couples from Point Pleasant, Roger and Linda Scarberry, and Steve and Mary Mallette, told police they saw a large grey creature whose eyes “glowed red” when the car’s headlights picked it up. This encounter would set the tone for a year of terrifying encounters and light a wildfire of controversy all over the country. This is the encounter that drew John Keel to Point Pleasant and made the Mothman a household name. 


Campfire: Tales of the Strange and Unsettling is created for adult audiences only. The content and discussion in this show will necessarily engage with various accounts that include violence, anxiety, fear, and occasional body horror. Much of it will be emotionally and intellectually challenging to engage with. We will flag especially graphic or intense content so as to never put you in an uninformed or unprepared position. We will do our best to make this a space where we can engage bravely, empathetically, and thoughtfully with difficult content every week. 

This week’s episode includes descriptions/sound related the following sensitive content:

Violence Against Animals

High Stress Situations

High Speed Pursuit


Check it Out!

Mothmen 1966


Mothman Archive

Woodrow Derenberger Interview

Visitors from Lanulos

The Mothman Prophecies: A True Story

John Keel

Check this out on Amazon

Strange Creatures From Time and Space

John Keel

Check this out on Amazon

The Silver Bridge

Gray Barker

Check this out on Amazon

Real Monsters, Gruesome Critters, and Beasts from the Darkside

Brad Steiger

Check this out on Amazon

Mothman: The Facts Behind The Legend

Jeff Wamsley

Check this out on Amazon

Small Town Monsters: The Mothman Trilogy


Support Campfire on Patreon:

Satisfy All of Your Merch Needs:

Join the conversation on social media at 






Visit Our Linktree for Any and All Campfire Info:

Special Thanks:

Gregg Martin for music contributions! Go follow him on Instagram at , on Bandcamp at or on Spotify at

Additional Music & SFX Provided By:

Elias Armao for graphic design! Go follow him on Instagram at 

Jonathan Dodd for merch design! Show him some love at

Easton Chandler Hawk! Support his work at

Christina at The Crescent Hare! Support everything she does at

Todd Purse at Create Magic Studios! Support his work at

About the Author
Hosts Ryan and Jordan deliver terrifying tales of the paranormal and break them down for your listening pleasure.